Problems in Greek history

Problems in Greek history

Even since the following sheets were printed, the researches into prehistoric Greek life, and its relation both to the East, to the Homeric poems, and to the Greece we know in the 7th century B.C., have progressed, and we are beginning to see some light through the mist. I can refer the reader to two books, of which one has just been published in English. The other, the second edition of Busolt's History of Greece, though still in the press, will be accessible to those that read German in a few weeks. I prefer to cite the formerSchuchardt's account of Schliemann's Excavationsin its English form, as it is there enriched with an Introduction, and apparently a revision of the text, by Mr. Walter Leaf. This is the first systematic attempt to bring into a short compass, with the illustrations, and with some regard to chronology, the great body of facts discovered and hastily consigned to many large volumes by the gifted discoverer. There is, moreover, a separate chapter (vi.) which gathers these facts under a theory, not to speak of the acute and cautious criticism of Mr. Leaf, which will be found in the [vi]Introduction to the volume. The Introduction to Busolt's History, of which (by the author's courtesy) I have seen some 130 pages, contains a complete critical discussion of the same evidence. Here is the general result in Busolt's own exposition (G. G. 2nd ed. pp. 113 sq.): 'The Homeric culture is younger than the Mykenan, it is also simpler and in better proportion. The former had come to use iron for arms and tools, the latter is strictly in the age of bronze[vi:1]. If the culture of the Epics does show a lower stage of technical development, we perceive also a decline of oriental influences. In many respects, in matters of interment, dress and armour, the epic age contrasts with the Mykenan, but in many points we find transitions and threads which unite the two civilizations. The Homeric palace shows remarkable agreements with those of Myken and Tiryns. The Homeric heroes fight with sword, spear, and bow, like the Mykenan. Splendid vases, too, and furniture, such as occur [vii]within the range of the Mykenan culture, agree even in details with the descriptions of the Epos. The Epos, too, knows Myken "rich in gold," and the "wealthy" Odeomenos. In general the homes of the Mykenan culture are prominent in the Iliad. The splendour of the Mykenan epoch was therefore still fresh in the memory of the olians and Ionians when the Epos arose. 'If the life thus pictured in the Epos thus shows many kindred features to that of Myken, the Doric life of the Peloponnesus stands in harsh contrast. Not in strong fortresses, but in open camps, do we find the Dorian conquerors. The nobles do not fight on chariots in the van, but serried infantry decides the combat[vii:1]. ......Buy Now (To Read More)

Product details

Ebook Number: 36354
Author: Mahaffy, J. P. (John Pentland)
Release Date: Jun 8, 2011
Format: eBook
Language: English